Correct the smallest supported fact

Classify the problem, confirm the version, choose evidence close to the fact, and record what changed.

  1. First confirm that every source describes the same recording.

  2. Prefer direct evidence and identify what remains uncertain.

  3. Keep the earlier record so a correction has an audit trail.

  1. Start by classifying the reported problem

    A wrong lyric word, missing featured artist, bad chart rank and mistimed line are different problems. Each one needs different evidence. A correction form should identify the URL and the exact field instead of asking an editor to replace the whole page.

    Copyright notices use a separate process because they concern authority to display material, not ordinary factual accuracy. Keeping those workflows separate helps urgent rights claims receive the required information.

  2. Confirm that the sources describe the same version

    Many apparent disagreements come from comparing an album version with a remix, clean edit or live performance. Check the full artist credit, duration, release and identifiers before deciding that one source is wrong.

    If the versions differ, preserve separate facts rather than blending them. A lyric line can be correct for one recording and absent from another. Timing must always follow the matched audio.

  3. Use evidence closest to the disputed fact

    For a lyric word, listen to the identified recording and compare any authorized text. For a writer, use supported composition credits. For a chart rank, use the dated chart snapshot. One famous database is not automatically the best source for every field.

    Screenshots and search snippets can lose dates or context. Preserve the original source URL, record ID or submitted evidence so another editor can repeat the check.

  4. Do not turn uncertainty into a confident sentence

    When audio is unclear or two reliable records disagree, narrow the claim. Leave a field blank, mark a word for review or explain that the available sources conflict. This is more useful than choosing the answer that looks most complete.

    A later source may resolve the gap. Clear uncertainty tells the next reviewer what evidence is missing and prevents a guessed detail from becoming the basis for more pages.

  5. Preserve the correction history

    Store what changed, when it changed and which evidence supported the decision. Approved community notes and editorial actions should remain attributable to the account or desk that handled them.

    An audit trail does not mean every private detail becomes public. Contact information and legal submissions remain protected, while the public page can show its current facts, stewardship and review state.

Match the disputed field to the closest evidence

A single source is rarely best for lyrics, credits, charts and recording identity at once. Start with the field that is wrong, then collect evidence suited to that field.

Reported problemFirst evidence to inspectCommon false conflict
Wrong lyric wordThe exact audio passage plus authorized text for that recording when available.Two sources describe clean and explicit versions.
Missing performerThe complete recording credit and the credited artist entities.A release page shortens a collaboration to one name.
Incorrect releaseEdition-specific release data, track sequence and recording identifiers.A deluxe reissue is mistaken for the first release.
Bad chart rankThe named chart's dated source snapshot.Peak rank is compared with current rank.
Lyrics drift during playbackCue times checked against the matched recording from beginning to end.The timing belongs to another edit with a different intro or section.

What to do next: Record the old value, proposed value, source and decision. If the evidence does not resolve the conflict, preserve the uncertainty instead of selecting the tidier answer.

When sources disagree

These answers explain what to do before replacing an existing word, credit or timing cue.

What if two lyric sources show different words?

First confirm the recording version. Then compare the audio and source authority for that exact line, and keep uncertainty visible if it remains unresolved.

Is a copyright complaint the same as a correction?

No. A correction addresses accuracy; a copyright notice addresses authority to display material and follows a separate legal workflow.

Why keep an audit trail after fixing a page?

It lets editors repeat the check, prevents old errors from returning and makes the source of a material change accountable.

Accurate transcription, source quality and identifiers help isolate the fact that needs changing.